Are Impact Resistant Shingles Worth It? (7 Main Reasons)

When it comes to protecting your home’s roof, choosing the right materials is crucial. One option that has gained popularity is impact resistant shingles. These shingles are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, making them a valuable investment for homeowners. If you’re considering upgrading your roof, understanding the benefits and considerations of impact resistant shingles is essential. To explore professional roofing options tailored to your needs, check out our comprehensive roofing services.

• Stronger weather defense: Designed to resist hail, wind, and flying debris
• Lower repair costs: Reduces frequent fixes from storm damage
• Insurance benefits: Some providers offer policy discounts
• Longer lifespan: More durable materials increase roof longevity
• Better resale value: Adds security and appeal to your home
• Peace of mind: Protects your home in unpredictable weather
• Smart investment: Offsets higher initial cost with long-term savings

Why Impact Resistant Shingles Matter for Modern Roofs

Impact resistant shingles have become an important consideration in roofing, especially in areas prone to hail, strong winds, or falling debris. Their advanced design helps protect your roof from costly damage that can result from severe weather. Homeowners investing in these shingles often find that they improve overall home safety and reduce insurance premiums.

• Durability: Engineered to resist impacts from hail and debris, reducing the risk of cracks and breaks
• Weather Protection: Offer superior resistance to wind uplift and water penetration
• Extended Lifespan: Usually last longer than conventional shingles due to enhanced materials
• Insurance Savings: Some insurance companies provide discounts for homes fitted with impact resistant roofing
• Increased Property Value: Boost your home’s resale appeal with shingles that provide added security and style

7 Main Reasons Impact Resistant Shingles Are Worth the Investment

These shingles are more than just a roofing upgrade — they’re a long-term investment in home protection. Here are the top seven reasons they’re worth it.

1. Superior Protection Against Hail Damage

Impact resistant shingles are tested to perform under severe impact from hail. They’re crafted with stronger materials that can absorb impact without breaking or losing granules.

• Hail Resistance Class: Rated Class 4 — the highest impact resistance standard
• Advanced Composition: Often made with rubberized asphalt or reinforced fiberglass

2. Resistance to Wind and Flying Debris

These shingles are designed to remain secure during wind gusts that would normally dislodge traditional shingles. This is especially valuable in storm-prone areas.

• Wind Rating: Many products can withstand winds of 110 mph or more
• Storm Durability: Helps prevent shingle blow-off and water intrusion

3. Reduced Long-Term Maintenance

Thanks to their resilient build, impact resistant shingles require fewer repairs over time compared to standard shingles, which often crack or degrade sooner.

• Fewer Replacements: Less risk of cracked or missing shingles after storms
• Lower Maintenance Costs: Reduces need for ongoing patchwork

4. Potential Insurance Discounts

Many insurance companies reward homeowners for installing roofing materials that lower the risk of claims. Impact resistant shingles often qualify.

• Premium Savings: Discounts vary by provider and region
• Certification Required: Proof of installation or product documentation may be needed

5. Extended Roof Lifespan

Because they hold up better under pressure, these shingles typically extend the life of your roof by several years or more.

• Durability Over Time: Resistant to granule loss, cracks, and weathering
• Long-Term Investment: Pays off with fewer major repairs and replacements

6. Curb Appeal and Style Variety

Impact resistant shingles now come in a wide range of colors, textures, and profiles, allowing you to maintain or upgrade your home’s look.

• Architectural Options: Available in designer styles and dimensional finishes
• No Aesthetic Trade-Off: Protection without sacrificing appearance

7. Peace of Mind in Extreme Weather

Knowing your roof is equipped to handle whatever nature throws its way is one of the biggest advantages.

• Protection During Storms: Minimizes risk of leaks or internal damage
• Home Safety: Helps keep your property and family secure

Additional Considerations When Choosing Impact Resistant Shingles

Before committing to this upgrade, weigh these important factors that can influence your decision.

Upfront Cost vs. Long-Term Value

Impact resistant shingles cost more initially, but the added value through fewer repairs, longer service life, and insurance savings can offset this cost over time.

Local Climate Risks

Homes in hail-prone or high-wind regions like Brunswick, OH, benefit the most from this upgrade. Evaluate your area’s history of storm activity to decide if it’s the right fit.

Quality of Installation

Proper installation is crucial. Choosing experienced roofing contractors ensures your shingles perform as intended and that you maintain eligibility for manufacturer warranties.

Compatibility With Your Roof

Most homes can accommodate impact resistant shingles, but roofs with complex angles or structural issues may need modifications before installation.

How Impact Resistant Shingles Compare to Other Roofing Materials

Here’s a look at how these shingles perform compared to other popular options:

Feature	Impact Resistant Shingles	Traditional Asphalt Shingles	Metal Roofing	Tile Roofing
Impact Resistance	High	Low to Moderate	High	Moderate
Lifespan	20–30 years	15–25 years	40–70 years	50+ years
Cost	Moderate to High	Low	High	High
Maintenance	Low	Moderate	Low	Moderate
Weather Resistance	Excellent	Good	Excellent	Good

Common Questions About Impact Resistant Shingles

Many homeowners have questions when considering impact resistant shingles. Here are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions that can aid your decision process. These shingles are an investment, so it’s important to understand how they perform in your specific region and roofing structure.

Will impact resistant shingles work in all climates?

Yes, while they are ideal for hail and wind-prone areas, their durability and long lifespan make them suitable for various climates.

Do insurance companies always offer discounts?

Not always, but many do. Contact your provider to confirm eligibility and documentation requirements.

How do I know if I need impact resistant shingles?

If your roof suffers frequent damage from storms or hail, upgrading to these shingles can significantly reduce future repair costs.

Can they be installed on my existing roof?

Most likely. A roofing professional can assess whether your current structure is ready or if a tear-off is needed before installation.

Upgrade Your Roof With Buckeye State Roofing

Are impact resistant shingles worth it? Absolutely — especially if you live in areas vulnerable to hail or severe weather. With benefits like better protection, fewer repairs, and insurance savings, they provide smart long-term value.

We’re proud to serve home and business owners in Brunswick, OH, and surrounding communities with advanced roofing solutions including impact resistant shingles. For a professional evaluation or to get started on your new roof, contact Buckeye State Roofing today.